Posted: December 4th, 2022

law

TOPIC 300 Words

1. Review all posted Reading Assignments, especially the Instructor Powerpoint and Instructor Lecture.

2. Choose only ONE of the following options.  You may choose Option A or Option B for your Discussion Board initial post.  Whichever option you choose, your initial essay should be 300+ words (content) and thoughtfully answer all posed questions in one single essay.

Indicate which option you chose in your post subject line.

OPTION A
State of North Carolina v. Robertson (2000): Larceny or Robbery?

a.  Read the court case

State of North Carolina v. Willie Herbert Robertson, 531 S.E. 2d 490 (2000)
. (This link opens in a separate browser window)

b.  Review the following North Carolina statutes in the Instructor Powerpoint and in the NCGS:

· Common Law Robbery (NCGS 14-87), Assault with a Deadly Weapon with Intent to Kill Inflicting Serious Injury (NCGS 14-32(b)),  Felonious Larceny (from the person) (NCGS 14-72(b)(1)).

c.  Answer the following questions in one essay containing 150+ words (content):

· What crimes was Robertson initially charged with and why?

· Based on the facts of the case, do you feel that the court ruled correctly in not allowing an imperfect defense of Voluntary Intoxication for either of the two original charges?  Why or why not?

· Based on what you have read, do you feel that the level of force was enough to qualify for the charge of Common Law Robbery?  Or did the court rule correctly in choosing the lesser charge on appeal?  Explain your reasoning based on the elements for these crimes.

· What would have had to occur in this scenario in order for you to change your mind and choose the other charge?  Explain.

OPTION B:  Larceny of a Motor Vehicle in North Carolina.

a.  Read the UNC School of Government blog post

North Carolina Criminal Law: Larceny of a Motor Vehicle

.  (This link opens in a separate browser window)

b.  Review the North Carolina statute on Larceny (NCGS 14-72) and any other relevant statute discussed in the post.

c.  Answer the following questions in one essay containing 300+ words (content):

· In your opinion, should there be a specific statute for Motor Vehicle Theft in North Carolina?  Why or why not?

· If such a statute was created, what would it look like?  In other words, what elements would, or should be included in such a statute?

· Should the penalties be different for motor vehicles than for other types of stolen merchandise or items?  Explain.

· Do you feel that North Carolina should have a specific statute for carjacking?  Or should this crime be charged as it is currently under the Armed Robbery or Common Law Robbery statutes?  Discuss your answer.

Resources

https://www.leagle.com/decision/20001021531se2d49011003

Expert paper writers are just a few clicks away

Place an order in 3 easy steps. Takes less than 5 mins.

Calculate the price of your order

You will get a personal manager and a discount.
We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00